[EAS] WEA is not a super-tweet: NL Police warnings about football match

Botterell, Arthur@CalOES Arthur.Botterell at CalOES.ca.gov
Thu May 25 12:29:32 CDT 2017


Sean, unless I'm mistaken the Dutch system predates both CMAS/WEA and was based on the 3GPP cell-broadcast specification, which later was also adopted in implementing WEA.  Indeed, there were folks advocating for adoption of cell-broadcast here in the States, and citing the Netherlands example, years before the 2006 WARN act mandated creation of what has become WEA.

The dozens of repeat NL-Alert messages sounds like a processing foul-up, not unlike what happened in Pennsylvania... or, to recall the canonical example, like the 1971 "wrong paper-tape" EAN.  (Few stations actually activated... here's an aircheck from one that did: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yu4r79l8P8I).

Another reminder that power doesn't guarantee infallibility.

Art
________________________________________
From: EAS <eas-bounces at radiolists.net> on behalf of Sean Donelan <sean at donelan.com>

[snip...]
 The ETSI, european standard, for cell-broadcast alerts are based on the U.S. ATIS CMAS
standards. 
[...snip]



More information about the EAS mailing list