[EAS] Should the RWT EAS Code be abolished?

[David Turnmire]

On 11/24/2011 5:29 AM, Mike McCarthy wrote:
> I concur with the latter.  The former is loaded with logistical problems
> of syncing stations to forward any messages however.
I don't think I understand what you are saying here.  Can you clarify?
> As with many systems, failure to test will lead to a failure to operate
> when needed.  I believe a regular self-run test is necessary.  Just look
> at how many found the failing power supply problem on the Sage 1922, the
> complete ineptness of the Holly-Anne, or odd printing issues with the GR.
>
> The question remains how often.  I believe a weekly test seems
> appropriate and I don't see a problem with that requirement.
I agree the question is how often.  Certainly the power supply issue is 
a good example of something that often showed up when originating an 
alert... and there are other examples of its usefulness.  I don't really 
have any major heart ache over originating a weekly test without voice 
for end-of-the-chain stations... it doesn't tie up that much air time.  
On the other hand... the types of problems it is likely to catch don't 
occur real often and we still have the RMT.  And in my neck of the 
woods, there are typically some weather alerts during the month as 
well.  Sometimes LOTS.  So... as you say... the question is how often do 
we need to test that aspect at that point in the chain?

IMHO, the some of the participants that are most important to initiate 
RWTs are the vary ones that have NO legal responsibility to do so under 
current law... the civil authorities!
> I do
> however find fault with requiring the showing of manual RWT activation
> even if fully operating in automated mode.
I must have missed that requirement.  My organization hasn't done a 
manual RWT activation in many years!  Its all done by automation.  Most 
of our sites are unattended 24/7 and essentially relay programming from 
a central office (though with local EAS equipment).  Apparently the EAS 
equipment vendors have missed that requirement too... as the ones I have 
personal experience with all support a "RWTs at random times" feature.  
Can you point me to where this manual RWT activation requirement is?

Dave